Search

Mental health trust governor speaks out after restrictions on confidential papers after Panorama leak

PUBLISHED: 14:11 12 July 2017 | UPDATED: 17:44 12 July 2017

Hellesdon Hospital. Photo: NSFT

Hellesdon Hospital. Photo: NSFT

NSFT

Confidential papers will no longer been seen by governors of the region’s mental health trust after a set was leaked to the BBC’s Panorama programme.

Aired in February this year, the programme shone a light on the Norfolk and Suffolk NHS Foundation Trust (NSFT) and how the number of unexpected patient deaths at NSFT rose when the trust cut services as part of its “radical redesign”.

But after papers for the board of directors’ meeting were leaked to the show, governors will no longer receive confidential papers with the exception of the lead governor, who must discuss what other governors would see with board chairman Gary Page. But the move was slammed by one governor, who spoke to this newspaper anonymously and said: “There is considerable disquiet about the decision to withhold vital information. Many governors who are supportive of the NSFT board are unhappy with this decision.

MORE: Mental health trust under microscope: Panorama documentary ‘painted a bleak picture’

“The role of lead governor is only supposed to become prominent in moments of conflict with a trust board to allow a CoG to bypass the chair and directly communicate any serious concerns to the regulator of foundations trusts, Monitor. In essence, the lead governor has become a shadow director of the trust rather than a governor acting primus inter pares.”

MORE: The public must have a say in the future of healthcare provision in Norfolk and Suffolk

They added there was already tight control of the governors. They said: “These further changes make proper corporate governance virtually impossible. It is the fear of retribution, of the further withdrawal of information, that forces me to speak anonymously. It shouldn’t be this way.”

In a statement NSFT company secretary Robert Nesbitt said the trust would now follow standard foundation trust corporate governance procedures and the majority of trusts did not provide governors with private board papers.


MORE: What did we learn from Panorama? Reaction and analysis after spotlight is shone on region’s mental health trust

Guidance published by Monitor said “there is no legal basis on which the minutes of private sessions of board meetings should be exempted from being shared with the governors”. However, the lead governor would still be able to see these papers at NSFT.

MORE: Health secretary Jeremy Hunt told mental health Panorama was “shocking and disgusting”

Mr Nesbitt added: “Where items are taken in the private board sessions for reasons of confidentiality or commercial sensitivity they will be subsequently reported in public, where appropriate.”

What requires governor input?

When asked what the criterion would be for an item which needed governor input, Mr Nesbitt said governors were “the keystone of the trust’s accountability and strong governance.”

He said: “As set out in the Health and Social Care Act (2012), the overriding role of the council of governors is to hold the non-executive directors, individually and collectively, to account for the performance of the board of directors and to represent the interests of foundation trust members and of the public.

MORE: Unexpected deaths rise coincides with bed closures at region’s mental health trust, Panorama finds

“The board of directors is responsible for the direction and performance of the trust, while the council of governors is responsible primarily for assuring the performance of the board.”

However, the governor said: “Information is now shared on a purely subjective basis of ‘who can be trusted?’ and ‘what do chosen governors need to know?’. This is too close to ‘who do we like?’ and ‘are they one of us?’ for comfort.”

Other news

06:00

The mother of an RAF soldier who died in a motorcycle is taking on an unusual fundraising activity to raise money for the air cadets, an organisation she says helped to shape her son’s career.

58 minutes ago

The family of a woman who took her own life have told an inquest she was a “brilliant mum” who loved her children and took pride in her work.

Yesterday, 18:25

Commuters are facing delays in Dereham this evening after a crash.

Yesterday, 14:43

They are our very own beasts from the deep. But it seems that the famous North Sea crabs have met their match - in the shape of the Beast from the East.

Most Read

06:00

The mother of an RAF soldier who died in a motorcycle is taking on an unusual fundraising activity to raise money for the air cadets, an organisation she says helped to shape her son’s career.

Read more
Netherlands
58 minutes ago

The family of a woman who took her own life have told an inquest she was a “brilliant mum” who loved her children and took pride in her work.

Read more
Norwich
Yesterday, 18:25

Commuters are facing delays in Dereham this evening after a crash.

Read more
Yesterday, 14:43

They are our very own beasts from the deep. But it seems that the famous North Sea crabs have met their match - in the shape of the Beast from the East.

Read more
United Kingdom
Yesterday, 11:30

A woman who has brought life-changing experiences to dozens of young people has been awarded the Fakenham Mayor’s Community Award.

Read more

Most Commented

06:00

The mother of an RAF soldier who died in a motorcycle is taking on an unusual fundraising activity to raise money for the air cadets, an organisation she says helped to shape her son’s career.

Read more
Netherlands
58 minutes ago

The family of a woman who took her own life have told an inquest she was a “brilliant mum” who loved her children and took pride in her work.

Read more
Norwich
Yesterday, 18:25

Commuters are facing delays in Dereham this evening after a crash.

Read more
Yesterday, 14:43

They are our very own beasts from the deep. But it seems that the famous North Sea crabs have met their match - in the shape of the Beast from the East.

Read more
United Kingdom
Yesterday, 11:30

A woman who has brought life-changing experiences to dozens of young people has been awarded the Fakenham Mayor’s Community Award.

Read more

Local Weather

Partly Cloudy

Partly Cloudy

max temp: 13°C

min temp: 13°C

Show Job Lists

Digital Edition

Image
Read the Dereham Times e-edition today
E-edition

Newsletter Sign Up

Sign up to receive our regular email newsletter